What does fast food in Hicksville taste like? Well, it depends who you ask. Our options are plentiful and ever-evolving, but it’s also easy to settle for a disappointing drive-thru variation. So compiling a list of Hicksville’s essential quick bites, both brilliant and memorable, isn’t simple. We’ve gathered a few totem dishes from our local favorites, as well as some surprising outliers. All of these are icons in their own right, whether it’s a perfect burger or a plate of majestic fries.
Potato Corner
$ | (516) 939-0679 | WEBSITE
The most popular fast food spot in the mall has a few contenders for signature items, but it’s hard to look past the garlic parmesan fries. They arrive in a red cardboard boat with a generous portion of well-cooked fries, a light dusting of seasoning, and a small cup of dipping sauce. Never have potatoes looked so tempting, and crispy fries coated in savory garlic parmesan, with a dip of creamy sauce, is fantastic.
The chicken wings combo with loopy fries is another winner, arriving hot and perfectly seasoned. While the sauce portions could be more generous, asking for extra seasoning makes all the difference. At around $8-12 for a satisfying meal, it’s a solid value for families craving quick, tasty comfort food in the bustling mall setting.
CROWN CHICKEN AND GRILL
$ | (516) 490-5555 | WEBSITE
Like burgers, sandwiches, and seafood specials, many Hicksville residents’ favourite comfort food is based around convenience. But there’s something special about Crown Chicken And Grill. It’s best to come to this humble spot early-ish, when the fried chicken is cooked perfectly and the French fries are smoking fresh, and your meal is soundtracked by the friendly chatter from the peaceful dining area.
Taco Bell
$ | (516) 935-0914 | WEBSITE
This is a fast-food institution. It has convenience, efficiency, affordability, reliability. OK, forget that last one, but Taco Bell is a dependable, American bastion of quick satisfaction in Hicksville and this is their straightforward, consistent staple. On the outside, uniform rectangles of crunchy taco shells from their standard supplier. Inside, a line of seasoned ground beef standing ready and an absolute flavor-booster serving of fire sauce and creamy jalapeño.
Jersey Mike’s Subs
$ | (516) 730-9500 | WEBSITE
One visit to this sandwich shop in Hicksville and you’ll feel like a Philly cheesesteak has taken up permanent residence in your taste memory and refuses to vacate. These sandwiches are as juicy as a summer peach, the Italian sub is a certified heavyweight, and ordering them ‘Mike’s Way’ makes us feel satisfied in the way other (less hungry) people do when they finish a marathon.
New Hot Breads
$ | (516) 470-0786 | WEBSITE
The vegetarian pizza is Hicksville’s most iconic dish; the version you’ll find at New Hot Breads is an entirely different experience. Since discovering this cozy spot, the charming bakery has served this cheesy, vegetable-topped creation that’s a far cry from anything you’d get at a typical fast-food joint. The eggless pistachio cake shines with flavor, the butterscotch cake is perfectly sweet, and the cardamom tea provides that necessary aromatic warmth.
Tex’s Chicken And Burgers
$ | (516) 822-2400 | WEBSITE
If New Yorkers survive on pizza, Chicagoans on deep-dish, what is it for Hicksville? Let’s go with fried chicken. The crispy bird can be found all over, but head to Tex’s Chicken And Burgers on its unassuming strip to be reminded of the reliable comfort of this handheld meal. The chicken is fried fresh to a golden-brown crisp, with flavourful seasoning and a generous handful of halal-certified care, and served with thick-cut fries that have just the right amount of give.
Holy Cow
$ | (516) 629-7555 | WEBSITE
Smash burgers, spicy fried chicken, mixed sliders. There are plenty of items you could order from Holy Cow, but absolutely shouldn’t. There’s a reason the majority of families in the clean, kid-friendly space are unwrapping their meals to reveal the specialty burger with brisket and short rib. Because it’s a knockout. The meat is hand-slaughtered and halal-certified, the fries crispy and well-seasoned, the vegetarian options satisfying, and the service timing impeccable even during busy hours.
Shah’s Halal Food
$ | (516) 261-9444 | WEBSITE
There are a few things you should know when you order at Shah’s Halal Food. The first is that no matter what you get, you should definitely ask for extra white sauce. The second is that the combo platter should only be tackled with a fork and plenty of napkins. The third is the falafel. Don’t skip it.
McDonald’s
$ | (516) 681-2434 | WEBSITE
Maybe it’s nostalgia calling, but McDonald’s classic cheeseburger does taste better than at other franchises. Fresh from the grill, it’s got that familiar, slightly crispy exterior, and the patty is surprisingly juicy. The ‘play area’ element is pretty spectacular, but we’re not going to argue with Antonia. Combine with fries and a Coke.
House of Heros
$ | (516) 939-6670 | WEBSITE
A Korean BBQ chicken wrap that also feels like the first bite of a homecoming feast, House of Heros’ signature creation has been legendary since day one. The perfectly grilled chicken wrap is paired with a generous, savory sauce and a crisp, fresh lettuce leaf. It’s satisfying, it’s kind of nostalgic, and there’s nothing like it anywhere else.
Kong Dog
$ | (516) 342-9930 | WEBSITE
This is a town of classic hot dogs. And yet, unassuming Korean spot Kong Dog has made such a name for its corn dogs that any day now someone will put up a sign on Hicksville’s main strip reading ‘Long Island’s best corn dogs, 2023-present’. They’re fried to perfection, more satisfying than your average fast-food run, with a crispy potato coating that’s about as subtle as a fireworks show. Sizzle on, legends.
Slappin Chick
$ | (718) 569-5580 | WEBSITE
In the crowded landscape of fast-food chicken, these tenders are a revelation. They were first discovered, devoured, and reordered at a quick-service spot in Hicksville in 2024, and you’d be forgiven for thinking that Long Island hadn’t made a decent chicken tender prior. It’s a Popeyes-inspired piece of craftsmanship—all crunch, flavor, lemon pepper seasoning, and Slappin sauce.
Gyro Spot
$ | (516) 822-0207 | WEBSITE
Gyro Spot has become a destination restaurant for Mediterranean food for many people in Hicksville, and the journey many make from Queens for its bun kebab plays a big role in that. Packed with spices and satisfyingly grilled to perfection, this sandwich is irresistible in flavor and is priced at just under $10 a plate. Order with extra fries.
Teriyummy Japan
$ | (516) 933-8883 | WEBSITE
Teriyummy Japan has become a go-to for Japanese fast food in Hicksville and like the rest of the offerings, there’s something to be said for the reliability of the tofu and vegetables over time and in this food court location. The satisfying steamed vegetables come with fluffy rice and a savory teriyaki glaze. Among the quick options, it should always be on the list.
Chick-fil-A
$ | (516) 433-6305 | WEBSITE
When Chick-fil-A opened in Hicksville, the drive-thru line wrapping around the building became as much a signature as the chicken sandwich. Now, the line has shortened, but customers still fill the spacious dining area for the tender, flavorful chicken sandwich. Served with a side of crispy waffle fries, it’s a satisfying meal (although the buttery, flaky breakfast biscuit still takes first place).
Peri-Peri GUYS
$ | (516) 470-0303 | WEBSITE
Behold, the humble plate of BINGO WINGS that kickstarted The Great Fast Food Revival Of ’26. Like all the best peri-peri dishes, it’s intensely flavorful with enough freshly ground spice to induce something we like to call the sexy heat-triggered taste bud tingle. Hafeez may be to blame for your mate’s kink for ‘saving the robot server’, but this halal peri-peri poster child still has our hearts.
Wendy’s
$ | (516) 433-0255 | WEBSITE
After a drive-thru run at Wendy’s, you brace yourself for two inevitable questions: ‘did you try the Loaded Fries?’ and ‘did you get the Bacon-Free Chili?’. At this fast-food staple, those crispy golden fries are craved like a classic comfort food. They’re piled high with melted cheese and toppings before being served steaming hot—yes, fast food can be comforting. A sprinkle of seasoning finishes this satisfying snack, which rivals any burger joint’s signature item.
Five Guys
$ | (516) 822-8022 | WEBSITE
There are burgers, and there’s Five Guys. The hefty all-American creations at this Hicksville spot are made to order and piled high with fresh never frozen beef, a generous heap of crisp lettuce and tomatoes, a swipe of tangy mayo, a handful of hot fries on the side, and a thick shake for good measure. It’s the kind of satisfying meal you’d crave after a long day, but far better executed.