There are moments when only a perfectly blistered crust, bubbling mozzarella, and tangy tomato sauce will satisfy that deep craving. Whether this hits you on a random Tuesday or every single Friday night when you’re deciding what to order, you need this list. Here are the seven best pizza spots in Galesburg, ready to answer that call.
Pizza Hut
$ | (309) 342-2717 | WEBSITE
This pizza joint will keep your table full until you tap out. Located in a busy strip in Galesburg, this popular restaurant offers a rotating selection of pizzas, including the pizza melt, for around $15 per person. Keep this place in mind for a big weekday lunch—which ends at 2:30pm—or a weekend dinner feast with friends who are down to sample whatever cheesy specials the staff brings over.
If it’s bright out, grab a seat in their newly remodeled dining area which overlooks a lively stretch of Main St.
Pizza Ranch
$ | (309) 351-7860 | WEBSITE
As you can probably tell from the name, you should order fried chicken here. This family-friendly restaurant in Galesburg serves a wide variety of options, including juicy pizza and tender chicken, catering to different dietary needs. The crispy coating on every piece comes out golden brown, and you can add on a large side of pizza for sharing. Our top pick is the delicious fried chicken, which tastes like a mountain of herbs and spices, and the good pizza, which is loaded with fresh toppings.
Pizza Ranch also has some game room entertainment on the premises that is pretty great, too.
Jimmys Pizza
$ | (309) 297-4064 | WEBSITE
The area near the train station in Galesburg is home to some of the best pizza spots in town. Jimmy’s Pizza is our favorite of the bunch. This classic specializes in exceptional quality pizza and onion rings that receive high acclaim. The dining room is much cozier than it looks on the outside and is filled with comfortable seating that’s ideal for a family dinner when you know kids will be joining at the last minute. There’s also a seamless service from the friendly and attentive staff.
The calming music playing in the background adds to the home-like atmosphere, making this a highly recommended spot for its delectable cuisine and welcoming ambiance.
baked (pizzas)
$ | (309) 297-4267 | WEBSITE
Galesburg has no shortage of classic pizza joints: the deep-dish at Tony’s, the thin-crust at Luigi’s, everything at Pizza Palace. It’s time to add Baked’s eggplant parmesan pizza to the list. The family-friendly spot in downtown Galesburg has a creative menu of excellent options like smoked brisket pizza and French onion pizza, but the eggplant parmesan will forever be what makes this quirky, inviting restaurant a destination.
Crisp, fluffy, and deeply flavorful—it’s one of the most balanced and satisfying pies we’ve ever eaten, and the kind of pizza that every local should be required by law to try at least once.
Budde’s Pizza & Spirits
$ | (309) 343-3502 | WEBSITE
If there’s one thing to order at Budde’s Pizza & Spirits in Galesburg, it’s the classic cheese pizza. The delicious pie features fresh ingredients and a perfectly balanced sauce, so it’s easy to grab a slice and enjoy. It comes topped with quality cheese that you can pair with things like their hazy IPAs, other craft beers, and maybe a side salad.
This is the ideal place to grab a casual weeknight meal in the neighborhood, which is when the atmosphere feels most welcoming, but you could also stop by for a relaxed weekend lunch.
The Pizza House
$ | (309) 343-8376 | WEBSITE
This charming family-friendly pizza spot offers comfort with a capital C. There are large windows on each side flooding the dining room with natural light and the space uses warm wooden furniture and soft lighting in a way that reminds us of a cozy neighborhood tavern. Plus, the food is just satisfying. Thick-crust pizzas come topped with ham and cheese, pepperoni, or fresh vegetables. Potato wedges are seasoned with herbs and served with ranch.
And our favorite is a wonderful salad—crisp greens, brimming with tomatoes, cucumbers, and house dressing. The crowd-pleasing menu and welcoming atmosphere here make The Pizza House one of our top family dining destinations in Galesburg.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (309) 344-3633 | WEBSITE
Little Caesars Pizza is one of the most reliable spots in Galesburg for a quick, satisfying meal, and one of our favorite places to grab a Hot-N-Ready pizza on a busy evening. These ready-to-go pies include a perfectly crispy crust with just the right amount of cheese and tangy sauce. Depending on what you order, you’ll get different combinations like their addictive crazy bread brushed with garlic butter or their popular crazy puffs.
Our favorite is their classic pepperoni pizza, which comes with that crispy crust to tear and dip into creamy sauces or enjoy on its own.