Marion has plenty of pizza joints where you can grab a slice with high schoolers and Little League teams, but it’s hard to find one where you can have a memorable pie. If that’s what you’re after, these are your best bets. From a wood-fired spot in a converted warehouse to a family-run joint downtown, all these places have crusts worth the drive and toppings you’ll dream about between visits.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (740) 383-3030 | WEBSITE
This pizza joint in Marion has a super clean setup, a friendly staff that makes you feel like you’re hanging with pals, and a step stool so kids can watch their pie being made. Whether you decide to grab a pickup order or opt for the impressively punctual delivery, make sure to get some fresh pizza and enjoy the awesome atmosphere.
Pizza Brothers Inc
$ | (740) 387-2121 | WEBSITE
Marion’s go-to pizza spot serves up world-class pies that locals swear by. From the team behind the area’s best pizza reputation, Pizza Brothers offers an airy yet dense crust with perfectly balanced sweet-savory sauce and a distinct homemade cheese blend. It’s satisfying and affordable, and if you don’t want a full pizza, there are fresh options like the BLT foldover or super duper chef salad.
The friendly staff remembers regulars, though service could be more attentive, and the lighting could be brighter. Still, for under $10, you get a good amount of food—try the iced cinnamon bread or breadsticks with pizza sauce too.
DB’S Rock’n Wing Truck
$ | (740) 692-6929 | WEBSITE
Food trucks are popping up in Marion like dandelions in spring. But there’s only one spot where the pizza toppings are so generous they practically spill over the edges. This mobile eatery has the quick service and wallet-friendly vibe of a classic family joint, only it’s rolling through town on four wheels. A full meal for a family costs under $50, and, while pizza and waffles are the main attractions, the star is that phenomenal pie. Savor every bite of that amazing pizza.
East of Chicago
$ | (740) 375-4300 | WEBSITE
This reliable pizza joint in the heart of Marion feels like the kind of spot you’d find in a bigger city. That said, East of Chicago has some of the best pan crust in town, and the pizza and subs are actually pretty good. Aside from a few larger items like a Taco pizza, you’ll mostly find solid takes on familiar take-out fare (thin crust with pepperoni, onions, and green peppers, classic subs, etc.). Grab dinner here, or bring a friend who just wants a tasty pizza on the go. They’ll be satisfied.
Genova’s pizza
$ | (740) 387-4992 | WEBSITE
Genova’s is named for the family that runs it, and if you’re unfamiliar with Marion pizza spots, it’s worth coming here just to try the fold overs that locals rave about. The menu isn’t super fancy, but they deliver a perfect pepperoni pizza with generous portions and a great Italian sub. There’s no table service here, which should be your first indication this isn’t a typical sit-down restaurant.
(Your second indication is that Genova’s closes at 10pm.) Still, this is a good option for casual group dinners when you want to get great value.
Pizza Hut
$ | (740) 387-2500 | WEBSITE
If you want to eat reliable pizza in Marion, you might as well do it at Pizza Hut. Both the service and the food here are consistently solid, so this place is a bit of a comfort zone, but one where the pizza is actually pretty great. You can either pick up your order at the counter or use the drive-thru or delivery. Unless you like waiting around for fancy service, we recommend the former. And in a rare plot twist, the buttery crust is some of the best things on the menu.
Bucci’s Italian Scratch Kitchen
$$ | (740) 751-4724 | WEBSITE
Bucci’s Italian Scratch Kitchen is the authentic sibling of typical Italian-American spots, offering scratch-made food in a converted storefront that feels like a piece of old-world Italy. Unlike chain restaurants, Bucci’s serves generous, flavorful dishes with reasonable prices—the Chicken Parm runs about $24, while pasta dishes like the meatball with penne in vodka sauce hover around $18.
You’ll likely remember the atmosphere more clearly than any single dish, but if all you want is to enjoy a quaint outdoor space with live music and hang out in a setting fit for rehearsal dinners or a casual night out, you can have a very nice time here.
Tubby’s Pizza
$ | (740) 382-2912 | WEBSITE
We mostly just go to Tubby’s for the pizza. The buttery crust and generous cheese are legendary, and there are lots of great classic options to choose from, like pepperoni and mushroom or a loaded pie with nearly everything. But there are plenty of tables where you can sit down for a full family gathering, and the subs are pretty outstanding. Think ‘off the charts delicious’ and double pepperoni with extra cheese.
Service is consistently great, so keep Tubby’s in mind for a last-minute celebration with some locals. They’ll love the welcoming atmosphere, childhood memories, and that the pizza tastes just like they remember.
Donatos Pizza
$ | (740) 389-3009 | WEBSITE
The pizza at Donatos makes every other pizza place in Marion seem boring. You can taste the quality in every bite from this spot on the main strip, so try to snag a booth in the beautiful dining room. The menu is pizza and subs, and, while that might sound simple, the food is actually pretty amazing. Choose from fairly priced options with generous toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and veggie combinations that are consistently accurate and on time.
Neighbors Pizza
$ | (740) 382-6595 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in a simple storefront in Marion, this local pizza spot is surrounded by neighborhood homes and family businesses, giving it an unassuming charm. The old-school pizza shop is a far cry from fancy chain restaurants, but the homemade pies are exactly what you want, and their delicious, in-house crust is Neighbors Pizza’s greatest asset. There’s plenty of seating inside, but grab a table if you’re dining in.
The friendly staff offers great service with super polite and cheerful employees, so it’s a convenient place for family dinners or after a long day. The menu includes vegetarian options and accommodates dietary restrictions, with recent orders like the big Block party pizza, cheesy bread, and stromboli leaving families happy. Despite its simple appearance, Neighbors Pizza remains a hidden gem and a favorite go-to spot for many in the neighborhood.
OK Cafe Marion,Ohio
$ | (740) 387-6565 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in Marion, Ohio, OK Cafe has a welcoming atmosphere that’ll make you swear you’ll never leave for any godforsaken town without a community spot like this one. Revamped by its current owners, this local gem serves wonderful bagels, pizza, salads, and subs and, famously, an impressive selection of bourbon. The fast, friendly, and generous service is worth the trip, but the family-like vibe is what makes this place a Marion staple.
Payne’s Pizza & More
$ | (740) 389-4732 | WEBSITE
The aroma that greets you when you walk into Payne’s Pizza & More is truly something. At this Marion restaurant, the food is just as comforting as the smell, and it’s all well-cooked—although the pizza flavors are ultimately pretty straightforward. It’s not the most adventurous cooking, but the generous toppings fit the local favorite experience. The crowd mostly consists of regulars from the neighborhood, with a subset that orders the Saturday Daily Deal for family dinners.
Whether or not that includes you, Payne’s Pizza & More is a good choice for when you need delivery that’ll please everyone at home.