Hicksville nails that whole suburb/city thing, with the pretty unbeatable combo of being able to experience Long Island charm while simultaneously feeling NYC’s pulse. Not surprisingly, a lot of people want to eat here, which, sure, has made parking on Broadway an absolute pain. But it’s also afforded us a far superior restaurant scene than we had, say, a decade ago.
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
$ | (516) 827-1234 | WEBSITE
If every busy corner had a spot like Tropical Smoothie Cafe, the world would be a better place. That’s because people would be too busy sipping perfectly blended smoothies and grabbing quick lunches to worry about traffic or whether or not people should check their phones while waiting in line (they shouldn’t, by the way). The fast-casual cafe takes staples like smoothies and lunch options and makes the best possible versions, all with friendly service and a space that feels clean and spacious.
Tom’s II Kitchen
$ | (516) 822-2442 | WEBSITE
Neighborhood Chinese spots often leave us craving something more, but not Tom’s II Kitchen, with all its authentic fried rice, tender twice-cooked pork, and accommodating low-fat options. Not to mention the boneless spareribs, which are so rich and flavorful they could pass as some sort of meat-based indulgence. While the local restaurant serves one of the best dinners in town, don’t overlook their weekday takeout.
The consistently good selection of dishes is worth making a return trip in the evening.
La Candela
$$ | (516) 470-0805 | WEBSITE
Mention La Candela to most people in Hicksville, and their eyes will probably light up. Whether it’s the best, most tender piece of anticucho con Rachi they’ve ever eaten, the hearty tacu tacu with steak, or, better yet, the ceviche that’s become a favorite after so much improvement, a lot of people have a memory of La Candela that makes them eager to come back.
And while there are so many different ways to do La Candela—outdoor seating when the weather permits, the cozy dining room with its nice decoration, and the comfortable atmosphere perfect for birthdays—the warm, attentive service from waiters like Yoel, Jonathan, and Sebastián is where you want to be.
House of Dosas
$$ | (516) 938-7517 | WEBSITE
This welcoming South Indian spot combines traditional recipes with accessible dishes. And while you may order counter-style, the dosas and thalis are way better than any chain, with options like the crispy Onion Rava Masala Dosa and the rich Cheese Pondicherry Dosa. You should also check out the attached ethnic store, where they sell ingredients like fresh coconut chutney, their signature spice blends, and even ready-to-eat meals perfect for busy families.
The fast and friendly service, especially from staff member Jai, makes the relaxed atmosphere even more enjoyable.
Pasta-eria
$$ | (516) 938-1555 | WEBSITE
Nestled in a warm and cozy space in the heart of Hicksville, Pasta-eria is an Italian restaurant with neighborhood vibes and a comforting soul. Checkered tablecloths and framed prints of Italian landscapes line the walls of the inviting, wood-accented dining room, where a varied menu of generous dishes featuring flavors from across Italy are served. Come with friends and build a feast with the Rigatoni Theresa, a regular slice of pizza many consider the best, and hearty Chicken Sinatra.
No matter what you order, the ample portions and delicious flavor combinations will satisfy any craving you bring, whether that’s for a classic pasta or one of their reliable heroes like the shrimp parm.
Uncle Don’s kitchen
$ | (516) 226-3808 | WEBSITE
Hicksville may not exactly be known for its Caribbean food—although there is something called “jerk chicken” around here, and if you’re curious, you should visit Uncle Don’s Kitchen for a taste. But there’s recently been something of a Caribbean food boom happening throughout the area. Regardless of where you’re from or what time zone you live in, Uncle Don’s makes exceptional homemade-style dishes loaded up with flavors like spicy beef patty, sweet plantains, and tangy pineapple ginger soda.
So long as it isn’t covered in a pile of snow, head out to the attached patio to escape the cozy indoor space (seriously, the whole restaurant feels like a family kitchen).
Singas Famous Pizza
$ | (516) 933-9033 | WEBSITE
It didn’t take long for people to latch onto Singas Famous Pizza—from the time it opened years ago, it’s been one of the busiest spots in town. Of course, it doesn’t help that the space is a bit worn (we’re talking your first apartment worn), so you should brace yourself before stopping in. Singas serves pizza with creative twists, like the Chicken Tikka Halal Pizza. The pizzas are the main draw, so this is the place to make a meal out of slices.
As for the vibe, well, the neon sign collection has got to be Hicksville’s finest, barring some rare pizza memorabilia collector we don’t know about.
Potato Corner
$ | (516) 939-0679 | WEBSITE
Finding a family-friendly spot in Hicksville that doesn’t break the bank is about as common as a quiet Saturday at Broadway Commons, which is why Potato Corner is worth weaving through the mall crowds for. The menu takes familiar comfort foods and elevates them with creative seasoning options, like garlic parmesan fries or Tods with that addictive sour cream & onion flavor. While the chicken wings combo with loopy fries is the best value here, the chicken tenders and sandwiches are solid as well.
The straightforward menu reads a little like someone took every kid’s favorite foods and gave them a gourmet twist—like extra-seasoned fries, perfectly cooked chicken fingers, and those generously portioned meals. The offerings are consistently satisfying and partially dictated by what families keep coming back for, but if the garlic parmesan fries are available, order them or regret it forever.
The space, in the mall’s center, is brightly lit and casually inviting, with a large counter, bustling energy, and family-themed atmosphere. It’s all so welcoming that we can overlook the occasional small sauce portion and our server’s enthusiastic recommendation to always ask for extra seasoning.
Chennai Dosas
$ | (516) 681-5151 | WEBSITE
Chennai Dosas is just as vibrant and flavorful as the South Indian cuisine it champions. Both center around tradition, with the restaurant’s story involving fresh ingredients and expertly crafted dosas. Your experience here should most definitely start with the famous Onion Rava Masal Dosa, served with its unique and delicious tomato chutney, and end with the best Gobi Manchurian we’ve ever tasted—crunchy, perfectly spiced, and utterly addictive.
The bustling dining area hums with energy via the non-stop flow of takeout orders and cheerful chatter, which we like to think of as cheering us on when we inevitably order one too many chutneys. The utilitarian space isn’t the spot for a quiet, intimate dinner amid dim lighting and plush seating, but you’re here for the food—and so is everyone else. Arrive early or be prepared to wait for a table in the compact dining room, as everyone’s vying for those generous portions here.
Guac Time Mexican Grill
$ | (516) 465-2042 | WEBSITE
One of the spots that’s been quietly perfecting authentic Mexican food in Hicksville, Guac Time has built its reputation on those birria tacos everyone keeps talking about. But really, it’s about more than just tacos—their pollo asado burrito wrapped in a warm, soft tortilla is another standout, packed with juicy chicken, fresh toppings, and just the right balance of rice and beans.
The former grab-and-go favorite has settled into a cozy, welcoming brick-and-mortar space, meaning no more guac drips on your car seats. Plus, the peaceful, relaxed atmosphere and spotless counters make it easy to enjoy your meal without any rush. The fresh ingredients and generous portions shine in every dish, from the loaded nachos to the caramel-filled churros, all served with friendly, attentive service that makes you feel right at home.
It’s the kind of place where you can unwind over a satisfying meal without breaking the bank, and leave already planning your next visit.
Applebee’s Grill + Bar
$$ | (516) 932-3780 | WEBSITE
Behind the counter at Applebee’s Grill + Bar is a dessert case displaying the triple chocolate meltdown. There may one day be statues erected to that dessert. Because while everything at Applebee’s is solid, the triple chocolate meltdown is exceptional. Rich layers sit atop a base of fudge and are then topped with an amount of whipped cream that could only be described as cloud-like. Applebee’s bills itself as a great environment for families and friends.
And while the space is casual and welcoming, the food lives up to the expectations set by its reputation. Aside from that dessert, get the wings—crispy and saucy served with celery and ranch that’s housemade and finished in the kitchen moments before they land on your table. The efficient staff members like Bec and Bryan make dining experiences enjoyable, and attentive management like Praj ensures everything is set for guests looking for a pleasant dining experience.
Pizza Hut
$ | (516) 935-3100 | WEBSITE
Yes, this is a pizza chain with consistently crunchy crusts and well-seasoned toppings that deliver every time, but what we can’t get over is the wing situation. The recommended wings come without sauce on the side, and you simply order them dry and dip as you like. Brilliant.
The pizzas come with all the classics, so you can pick among the signature pies with efficient delivery arriving earlier than expected, the new melt with its generous meat and cheese, and what could be the best cheesy bread in town. If you need more intel on the service, the younger employees and Store Manager are friendly and attentive, while the owner has been described as rude, so that’s probably all you need to know.
The Rabbit’s Foot
$$ | WEBSITE
The Rabbit’s Foot serves the kind of hearty, satisfying, and crowd-pleasing American fare that you can’t find anywhere else in town. That means new favorite dishes like perfectly crispy chicken wings with just-right heat, gnocchi bolognese that’s comfort food at its finest, and a giant cheesesteak egg roll that will ruin you for all other egg rolls.
(Always ask for extra fries with that burger.) Music lovers should grab a seat near the stage, where friendly staff will enthusiastically tell you about the night’s live performers. Otherwise, just book a regular table, and no matter where you sit, make sure you’re enjoying the pleasant, wheelchair-accessible atmosphere.